I suppose it would be best to explain my hardware setup before attempting to explain the problems I ran into. My setup would be much more easily explained in image form, so here it is. The dual monitors aren't really positioned the way they are in the diagram, but I'm sure you'll figure it out.
So after I had connected all the cables, I powered up my PC. The second monitor (the one I am switching with) was blurrier than the first monitor (plugged directly into the PC). According to the manual, this can be caused by improper cable setup (which I checked), cables that are too long (I doubt this was the case), and too high of a resolution. I was running both monitors at 1440x900. According to the product data sheet from the D-Link website, the switch supports resolutions up to 2048x1536.
The mouse decided to start going crazy once I started using it. Apparently this can be caused by PS/2 mouses with extra features such as a scroll wheel, and that generic PS/2 drivers should be enabled in the BIOS. I'm not willing to live without a scroll wheel. Not only did it have a scroll wheel, it was a USB laser mouse plugged into a USB-to-PS/2 adapter, so I'm not really surprised that it had problems. I did try a vanilla 3-button PS/2 trackball mouse, and it performed nearly perfect. Left click didn't work sometimes, but that could be the mouse itself. It's pretty old.
I powered up my Xbox 360 connected via VGA cable [xbox.com]. I then pressed the switch button on the KVM. The Xbox Dashboard flashed on screen for a moment, then disappeared, and the KVM switched back to my Linux desktop, notifying me with a beep both times. I thought maybe the resolution was set too high on the 360, even though the KVM claims to support up to 2048x1536. I connected the 360 directly to my monitor, lowered the resolution to 640x480, as low as it gets, and tried switching. Same problem.
There are several additional switching modes, accessible only by keyboard, so I decided to try those. The manual tells me to press the Scroll Lock Key twice, then a specific key for each mode. I'm looking and looking and eventually realize that my keyboard has no Scroll Lock Key. I looked into it and apparently most modern keyboards are being made without Scroll Lock [wikipedia.org]. I'm not surprised, when's the last time anyone used the scroll lock key? I realize that D-Link was trying to choose a key that was not commonly used in everyday keyboarding, as Ctrl, Alt, Shift, etc. are already taken. But instead of choosing a key that's going out of style, could they not have used a function key or something similar? I realize now as I type this that the odds of any PS/2 keyboard having a scroll lock key are actually pretty good, if they use the PS/2 connection.
After all these problems, I decided to try their tech support line. I got the phone number from a slip of paper from the package, waited on hold for ten minutes, only to find I had called the United States number. I was given the number for Canada, and waited another five minutes on hold. I explained my setup, and was informed that the model supports only Windows 2000, Windows XP, and Windows Vista. No other operating systems are supported. I may be wrong, but shouldn't the operating system not matter? The switch receives audio and video signals from either PC, then relays them to the hardware that is plugged in. As far as I can see, it has no reason not to work, regardless what operating system is running. I will look into it further though.
All in all, I had my hopes up for this setup. I can see why it's a little out of the ordinary compared to two plain old Windows PCs. I just wanted to be able to watch DVDs and play games on my Xbox, or switch to a dual-screen Linux setup for programming purposes. Hopefully I will be able to return or exchange the product for something better.
EDIT: I tried plugging the Xbox VGA cable into the switch just by itself, with no other PC. The switch started clicking and the power LED barely lit up. This leads me to believe that the Xbox VGA cable does not supply enough power for the switch through the VGA port. I think this means that I will have to find a KVM switch with its own power supply for this setup to work properly.
EDIT: For those of you wanting more information on a KVM that works in this configuration, I have a newer blog post about it.







